Exposé of Church Leader's Questionable Handling of Sexual Misconduct Allegations
- *
Allegations of Inappropriate Sexual Conduct Levied: Church Hierarchy Faces Scrutiny as Well - Proposal sought for workforce radiation safety directive, as commission instructed on related risks mitigation.
A scathing external review by Deloitte, commissioned by the church leadership of the Evangelical Church of Westphalia (EKvW), casts a critical eye on the role of former EKD chairperson Annette Kurschus in dealing with sexual misconduct allegations. The review calls out multiple missteps in handling these allegations.
Thegrim details of sexual misconduct against a church employee in the Siegen-Wittgenstein church district came to light in November 2023, eventually leading to Kurschus' resignation as chairperson of the Evangelical Church in Germany (EKD) and president of the Westphalian church.
The Controversy Surrounding Kurschus
In October 2022, a parish pastor alerted Kurschus to potential allegations of sexual violence. According to the Deloitte report, she shared this information within the church, but this move led to an internal power struggle and "eroded trust" at the EKvW leadership level.
"The passive communication strategy initially adopted by EKvW and Kurschus was misguided." This inaction triggered high media pressure and insufficient support within church committees, ultimately precipitating Kurschus' resignation. "In light of these lapses and other questionable connections, a legal review of potential misconduct by those involved is advised," the special report counseled.
A Timeline of Abuse: From the 80s to 2022
The disturbing allegations against the church musician were first revealed in a Siegen local paper. The Deloitte report indicates that seven victims have come forward, claiming sexual misconduct ranging from the 1980s to 2022. All were organ students. The accused admitted to sexual contact with two, but determining whether the victims were minors at the time is unclear. The former employee denies further advances or actions, but "this contradicts evidence gathered during the investigation," Deloitte revealed.
The Initial Response from the Church
The church hierarchy was aware of the allegations as early as the 90s, yet no formal investigation was conducted. Kurschus, a parish pastor in Siegen at the time, had a friendly relationship with the wife of the accused.
Kurschus' Departure: At Ease with Herself
Whispers of Kurschus' inaction in the face of the abuse allegations grew louder in the press. Kurschus justified her resignation from her top positions in November 2023, citing a loss of public trust but also asserted that she was "at peace with herself" regarding the matter: "I have always acted in good faith and conscience."
The Westphalian Church Owns Up to Its Failures
The fact that the accused was able to violate the sexual autonomy of his entrusted students for decades speaks volumes about the failure on the part of the Evangelical Church in Westphalia, acknowledged top clergy from the regional church (EKvW) and the church district of Siegen-Wittgenstein. "The Evangelical Church of Westphalia acknowledges and takes full responsibility for this failure toward the affected individuals and the public," said Ulf Schlüter, the theological vice-president of EKvW.
The Westphalian Church will be taking action based on the report, "review possible negligence by those involved, and further strengthen and enhance procedures for preventing and addressing sexual violence."
Schlüter noted that the church district of Siegen-Wittgenstein had established an intervention team in March 2023, imposed entry bans on the man, and reported the matter to the Siegen police. They had conversations with the victims and the intervention team is still working to clarify the facts. However, there were no commonly accepted standards or reliable processes in place for a unified, joint response from all levels of EKvW. Communication processes were inadequate and secretive.
Criminal Investigation Dropped
The Siegen police had dropped the investigations against the church employee over a year ago. From a legal standpoint, the man could not be accused of sexually abusing those under his care, the authorities stated. In the cases under scrutiny, either no criminal action was discernible or the cases were beyond the statute of limitations.
- Deloitte Report
- Annette Kurschus
- EKD
- Siegen-Wittgenstein
- Church Misconduct
- Westphalia
- 90s
- 1980s
- Conflict
- Media Pressure
- The Deloitte report criticizes Annette Kurschus, former chairperson of the Evangelical Church in Germany (EKD) and president of the Westphalian church, for her handling of sexual misconduct allegations in the Evangelical Church of Westphalia (EKvW).
- The sexual misconduct involved a church employee in the Siegen-Wittgenstein church district, with seven victims coming forward, claiming sexual misconduct that spanned from the 1980s to 2022.
- The report reveals that Kurschus was aware of the allegations as early as the 90s, when she was a parish pastor in Siegen, but no formal investigation was conducted.
- Kurschus' resignation in November 2023 was due to a loss of public trust, yet she claimed to be "at peace with herself" regarding the matter.
- The Westphalian Church acknowledges its failure in allowing the sexual misconduct to continue for decades and plans to review possible negligence by those involved, enhance procedures for preventing and addressing sexual violence, and improve communication processes.
- The Siegen police dropped the investigations against the church employee over a year ago, citing either no discernible criminal action or cases beyond the statute of limitations.
